by
secback
@ Friday, Jul. 13, 2007 - 11:19:01
They've been polling Americans about God again. It must be impossible to walk down the streets of Des Moines or Albuquerque without clipboarded young people demanding to hear your take on the ineffable. This time it's the Pew Research Center, who are at least well named for the job.
Many years ago a friend of mine was approached in the street by an interviewer with a camera crew. He went over, assuming he was about to get a chance to sound off about graffitti or the drains or something, and was asked "Would you wear a top hat in a room with a low ceiling?" He instinctively denied that he would. "How about if it was a formal occasion? Would you then?" He mumbled something and walked away. And that interviewer, ladies and gentlemen, went on to become Chris Morris.
Nothing so off the wall for the Americans, though, who were just asked what religion they were, whether they thought their holy book was literally true, and a variety of political questions.
There was the usual strangeness you get from US polls. For instance, 9% of Americans identify themselves as 'secular', and 9% of these say their holy book is literally true. Which book? The Origin of Species? The God Delusion? The Naked Lunch? Oh, please let it be The Naked Lunch.
You do wonder, though, don't you? 9% of 9% is near enough 1% of the whole population of America. That's 3 million people who think the holy book they don't have is literally true. Obviously we mainly pay such close attention to them because of their global economic and cultural hegemony, but you'd have to say they're also genuinely quite interesting.
Another striking result was that 68% of black Protestants believe in the inerrant Bible. That white evangelists believe this comes as no surprise, and that 50% of Muslims believe literally sounds about right, but I often think we underestimate the reactionary nature of the black churches because of their role in the civil rights struggle.
It's also very striking that Protestants should be so much more literal than Catholics. I suppose Catholics have learnt to take a more nuanced view so they can cope with all their gay priests.

If you consider political leanings by religion, a more predictable picture emerges. Evangelicals are conservative, black Protestants and Muslims are liberal and most people seem to think they're moderate, although what that means in the context I shudder to think.

Once we bring up gayness, of course, Muslims scuttle back into the reactionary fold. An impressive 43% of black Protestants, though, refuse to toe the Biblical line. Yes, that does imply that at least 11% per cent of them believe both that gaying up America is fine and that the rabidly homophobic Bible is literally true, but we'll take inconsistency over logically precise cruelty any day. Catholics are so relaxed on the subject they might as well start dressing up in frocks and waving incense about. Oh yeah. No wonder they're called seminaries.

And if you're wondering where the Jews have gone, I checked it out and they've declined to 1.4% of the population (2001 figures). This was down from 1.8% in 1990, so there's clearly something going on. It could be that there's a lower birth rate, but I expect it's mainly the consequence of generations of marrying out. If you've got one Jewish parent you might have some sense of being Jewish, but if you've got one Jewish grandparent that must fade, and one Jewish great grandparent must seem like just another family fact.
They've also discovered the brilliant trick of having a Holy Land that's a long way away. Every time one of their kids grows up all pious and irritating, before you know it he's shipped himself off to persecute Palestinians for Yahweh, leaving the rest of them to run theatres and art galleries in peace. It must have been a bit like that in Babylon, just after Cyrus said all the Jews could leave their lovely cosmopolitan city and crawl off back to their hideous little backwater, if they really thought God wanted them to.
Maybe there's a lesson here for us all. I've often wondered whether future generations of atheists might make a home out in space, on some tinpot hunk of rock, but maybe that's the wrong tack. If we could just find some Biblical verse which might be taken to mean that space exploration was some kind of spiritual duty, they might all fuck off to the asteroid belt, leaving the rest of us in peace on Earth.
If you're one of the few people not wandering the streets quizzing each other about the numinous, you may have noticed that the sea is rising. London is sinking into it, and in a few decades will presumably secede to the Empire of the Recently Deluged along with Venice and New Orleans, and eventually Bristol. On the plus side, as half our centres of civilisation sink under the waves, it will at least open the Northwest Passage. If only Frobisher and all the other reckless adventurers had known. All they had to do was wait for a few centuries, and The Great Corporate Reckless Adventure With All Our Lives would have solved their problem.
Headline of the week is British blamed for Basra badgers, a wonderful piece of alliterative weirdness. It seems that honey badgers have returned to the area, and a rumour has spread that the British planted them to attack local people unattributably. UK military spokesman Major Mike Shearer said: "We can categorically state that we have not released man-eating badgers into the area", and for once I'm prepared to believe him.
You have to wonder about people's judgement sometimes. I know the Army complain they're poorly equipped, but I don't think they're quite reduced to attacking the civil population with badgers. I'm sure they're quite happy beating people to death behind closed doors without resorting to the surreal.
Oh, and one late item to put all humanity's grand aspirations in context - How wearing underwear led to increased medieval literacy. Yes, it seems that after the Black Death there was such a mountain of unused clothes lying around they got made into paper for the newly founded printing industry. Even pants. There's a picture of some medieval pants, but they look implausibly clean to my eye. There's something quite grounding about the idea of Chaucer and Rabelais spreading their bawdy verse across Europe on some ground-up stinky old plague-ridden pants from a dead person. I'm sure they'd both have got the joke.
More polls here, here and here.